top of page

FEATURED PRODUCTS

Personal Best Fishing Challenge Coins

$34.99 Regular Price
$29.99Sale Price
Species
Largemouth Bass
Smallmouth Bass
Crappie
Sunfish
Catfish
Rainbow Trout
Walleye
Northern Pike
Mahi-Mahi
Red Snapper
Tarpon
Striped Bass
Swordfish
Goliath Grouper
Blue Marlin
Bluefin Tuna
Muskie
0/500
0/500
0/500
0/500
Quantity

Commemorate the catch of a lifetime with a fully custom, full color challenge coin printed right here in Wheeling, WV. Whether it's a trophy largemouth bass, a monster muskie, or a hard-fought saltwater giant — your personal best deserves more than just a photo.


Each coin features:


Your chosen fish species on the front — detailed, vibrant, full color

Angler's name, species, weight, and length printed on the back

Bold "PERSONAL BEST" arc across the top

Rich, vivid color that won't fade

Handcrafted and quality-checked individually


Available species include: Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Muskie, Walleye, Northern Pike, Rainbow Trout, Catfish, Crappie, Sunfish, Mahi-Mahi, Tarpon, Red Snapper, Striped Bass, Swordfish, Goliath Grouper, Hammerhead Shark, Blue Marlin, Bluefin Tuna — and more. Don't see your species? Just ask!


These make the perfect gift for:

  • Tournament anglers

  • Fishing buddies who just landed their PB

  • Father's Day, birthdays, or Christmas

  • Fishing clubs and organizations


How to order:

  1. Add to cart and purchase

  2. Send us your angler name, species, weight, length, and date via message

  3. We'll send a design proof before production

Ships anywhere in the USA — fast turnaround, no minimums

Your Life, Your Design. — Church's Customs

  • Privacy Policy

    Your personal information (name, address, order details) is used solely to fulfill your order and will never be sold or shared with third parties.

  • Return & Refund Policy

    Due to the custom, personalized nature of our challenge coins, all sales are final. We do not accept returns or exchanges on personalized orders.

    However, we will remake or fully refund your order if:

    • The coin arrives damaged or defective

    • There is a misprint or error on our end

    • The item is lost in transit

    If there is an issue with your order, contact us within 7 days of delivery with a photo of the problem and we will make it right — no questions asked.

    Please note: We are not responsible for errors in information submitted by the customer (misspelled names, incorrect stats, etc.), so please double-check all details before approving your proof.

    Order & Production Policy

    • All coins are made to order — production begins after you approve your design proof

    • Turnaround time: 3–5 business days after proof approval

    • A design proof will be sent before production — your approval is required to proceed

    • Orders cannot be cancelled or changed after proof approval and production has begun


    Shipping Policy

    • We ship anywhere in the USA

    • Orders are shipped via USPS First Class or Priority Mail

    • Tracking number provided on every order

    • We are not responsible for delays caused by USPS once the package is in transit

    • Lost or stolen packages — contact us and we will work with you to find a resolution

bottom of page